Best Value: EnterpriseVisit Site
The Best Car Rental Company
Ultimate Buyers Guide

The Best Car Rental Companies

Last Updated:

If you're like me, you'll probably find yourself in a situation where you'll need a car, but don't have one on hand and you don't know the best car rental company to turn to. Worse, once you find a car rental site, you'll need to find the right car for your needs, and make sure it's reliable.

As you can see, renting a car can quickly become complicated. Here, I've reviewed the best car rental sites to help you to make this decision more easily so you can get on the road with less hassle.

People decide to rent cars for all sorts of reasons, such as during a vacation, for special events and occasions, or even for business use. You will find all manner of vehicles available to rent from car rental companies these days. What you need to decide is which provider and vehicle will be best suited to your needs.

The Best Car Rental Companies: Our Top Picks

Enterprise Car Rental Review

  • Pros
  • Excellent choice of vehicles, including commercial trucks
  • Environmentally friendly vehicles
  • The ability to offset emissions
  • Long term rental plans with discounts available
  • Pick up and drop off the vehicle at different locations
  • Cons
  • Certain features such as roadside assistance cannot be arranged online
  • No search facility on the website to search for specific features

Enterprise Rent-a-Car is a big name in the world of car rentals and offers an excellent choice of vehicles to suit all needs and preferences. No matter what the occasion or what sort of car you require, chances are good that you will be able to find the perfect one through Enterprise. Better still, you will be able to check out the range of vehicles and make your rental arrangement via the company's simple and easy to use website, which can save you a lot of time, hassle and inconvenience. However, the online reservation is not completed until you actually pick the vehicle up.

The company website also offers a range of additional features to make life easier for those looking to rent a car, although regrettably a search tool is not one of these features. In addition to offering a wide variety of cars, this provider also offers commercial use trucks as well as hybrid cars with the environment in mind. You can even opt for a package that enables you to offset your emissions, which is great for those who want to do their bit for the green cause. There are various rental plans available, including long term rentals with a range of discounts based on the length of the rental.

Despite the several shortfalls that relate mainly to its website, Enterprise is a highly reputable rental service provider that offers great choice and environmentally friendly options.

Thrifty Car Rental Review

  • Pros
  • Feature rich website
  • 360 degree viewing feature
  • Competitive pricing on the cost of rentals
  • Fuel efficient vehicles
  • Best rate guarantee to ensure a low price
  • Cons
  • Limited environmentally friendly vehicles
  • No pickups or trucks available for rent
  • Limited customer service options

Thrifty car rental is another big name car rental company that offers a host of options when it comes to car rental. With a simple to use and feature-rich website, this car rental provider makes it easy to find the car you want for your needs without any hassle or inconvenience. You can look forward to competitive prices and plenty of choice, although the green options available are sadly lacking. It also does not offer pickups or trucks.

While the company does not offer much in the way of specifically environmentally friendly cars, it does pride itself on offering fuel efficient cars. This obviously does help to ease the impact of motoring on the environment and can also help customers in terms of the cost of motoring. One unique feature that comes with the Thrifty website is the ability to benefit from a 360 degree view of the vehicle you are thinking of renting. This makes it far easier to make an informed decision with regards to which car you choose.

Although it has some limitations when it comes to the availability of specific types of vehicles, Thrifty does offer a great choice of fuel efficient cars as well as competitively priced packages and great website features.

Hertz Car Rental Review

  • Pros
  • A reputable and well known rental company
  • A good website with plenty of features
  • A great range of vehicles including hybrids
  • Easy to personalize features
  • Online check in for ease and convenience
  • Cons
  • Lack of pickups or commercial trucks for rent
  • Car choices not as impressive as some rivals

When you rent a car through Hertz you can enjoy the peace of mind that you are renting through a well known, reputable provider that offers access to a range of vehicles to suit different needs. The simple yet highly effective website makes it easy for customers to find and rent a suitable car, with a valuable search tool that makes finding the right vehicle even easier. The range of vehicle models available from Hertz is pretty impressive, with cars, vans, luxury, convertible, and hybrid vehicles available.

There are no commercial trucks or pickups available for rent with Hertz, which is where the rental company may end up losing out to competitors. However, the company does excel at making it easy for customers to benefit from finding specific features that will suit their individual needs, so if you are not looking for a commercial truck or pickup you shouldn't have any problem finding a suitable vehicle. While online check in is available there are other services that cannot be arranged online and therefore you may have to wait until you collect your vehicle before completing the reservation.

While the choice of vehicles may not be as great as some other rental firms, this provider does offer a pretty good range for non-commercial needs.

Related: Compare Car Insurance Quotes

Key Considerations When Finding a Car Rental Company

The Best Car Rental Company

  1. Enterprise
  2. Thrifty
  3. Hertz
  4. Alamo
  5. Budget

Choosing the right provider as well as the right vehicle is an important part of enjoying a hassle-free car rental experience. This is why you need to take a number of important factors into consideration when deciding which car rental service to go with. This includes factors such as:

  • The choice of vehicles available from the provider
  • The reputation of the car rental company
  • The level of customer service offered by the rental firm
  • Competitive pricing on the cost of renting a vehicle
  • Additional features available with vehicles
  • Flexibility such as to make one-way or long-term rentals
  • Ability to make arrangements online

How to Choose the Right Car

Choosing the right car is just as important as choosing the best site for car rentals. With more than 2 million rentals cars in fleets across the United States, it can be difficult to find the perfect one for your trip.consider the following factors.

  • How many seats do you need in the car?
  • How much luggage needs to fit in the car.
  • Does the car rental service charge different amounts for different size cars? Can you save money by going down a size?
  • What fuel efficiency can you expect and how expensive is gas in the area? Gas prices across the country vary by 30% or more, so this can greatly affect the total cost of your rental.

Pay special attention to the car's ability to fit luggage and passengers, as nothing is worse than getting your car, and finding out you'll have to leave a suitcase behind.

Four Costs to Consider When Looking For a Car Rental Site

Car rental services, like any company, are in business to make money, even cheap rental cars are expensive to maintain, so companies need to charge a fair price to ensure they make a profit. When looking for the best place to rent a car, consider the following costs.

1. Gas and Mileage Fees

As more miles are put on a car, the moving parts and other machinery wear down. As anyone who's visited a mechanic can attest to, car parts often need to replaced or repaired to keep the vehicle running. Because the maintenance cost is so closely tied to how far the car is driven, car rental services often pass that cost onto you, adding a fee for every mile driven, or every mile driven over a base amount.

On top of that, cars need gas to operate. You are responsible for fueling the car while you rent it, and if you return the car with less gas than it had when you picked it up, the rental car service will charge you for the fuel, often at a higher rate than you'd pay at the pump.

2. Taxes and Fees

Where you rent a car can affect the cost of the rental as much as, or more, than the type of car you rent or the company you rent from. For example, airports are one of the most popular places to rent a car, since travelers need a way to get to their final destination. This means that car rental services can charge an additional fee thanks to the demand.

Some states also charge taxes on rental car services. Florida charges the state sales tax and a daily fee for rental cars. These can boost the cost of a rental car by as much as 70% when all is said and done.

3. Insurance

Cars cost tens of thousands of dollars so it is understandable that car rental services want assurance that they'll recoup the value of the car should it be damaged. For this reason, all of the best car rental companies require that customers have some form of car insurance.

If you already have insurance, most policies will cover vehicles that you rent. Additionally, some credit cards provide travel insurance that extends to rental cars, so long as you rent the car with credit. If your policy does not cover rental cars, or you don't have car insurance, you'll have to get the insurance offered by the company, which could increase your cost by 25% or more.

4. Extras and Add-ons

Upselling is an easy way for businesses to earn a bit more money from each customer and car rental services, economy car rentals especially, are just as guilty of it as other businesses. Sometimes these add-ons can be quite useful and make your trip easier, but other times, they are unnecessary costs that could have been avoided.

When you pick up the keys to your rental car, the company will offer extras like GPS navigation, car seats for children, or satellite radio. While any of these services could be useful, consider if you can avoid the cost with a bit of extra planning.

Five Tips for Saving

Once you've put in the time finding the best car rental site, the best car, and learning what hidden costs to watch for, you're ready to learn a few tricks that can help you save on your rental car.

1. Comparison Shop

The best car rental site for your specific needs can vary. Some car rental services specialize in certain vehicle types or areas, so taking the time to comparison shop can help you find the cheapest car rental you can.

2. Consider Who Will Do the Driving

Most car rental services won't add a charge to allow your spouse to drive a car you rent, but many will charge an additional fee to permit other people to drive the car. If you're only planning a short road trip, designating one person as the driver can save everyone some money.

3. Watch For Sales

Like any industry, the car rental industry offers sales to entice customers. Being flexible on the timing of your trip and waiting for a good deal can greatly reduce the cost of a rental.

4. Think Small

Car rental services tend to categorize, and price rentals, by car size. Smaller cars are cheaper while larger cars are more expensive. Try to rent the smallest car possible, while still having enough room for your family and luggage.

5. Use Your Own Insurance

The insurance offered by car rental services is valuable for people who don't carry their own car insurance, but it is also very expensive. Most car insurance policies will cover you when you are driving a rental car, so check if you can decline the rental service's insurance offerings. Even if you don't have your own car insurance, many credit cards, including nearly all Visa cards, come with free collision insurance on cars you rent with your card.

Small savings add up quickly, so taking the time to get the best deal possible is more than worthwhile.

Recap

There are many different rental vehicles to choose from as well as a number of different car rental companies. When you are making your selection you need to make sure you take into consideration both the suitability and choice of vehicles and the pros and cons of the providers in order to try and benefit from a stress-free rental experience.

Looking for great car insurance that will cover the car you rent on your next vacation? Check out our review of the best car insurance companies. If you already have a trip planned but want the peace of mind that travel insurance provides, take a look at our review of the best travel insurance available.

Car Rental Company FAQs

Q Do I need rental insurance?

A

There are a variety of factors that tell you whether or not you should buy car renters insurance and none of them are the savvy salesman across the rental counter. Rental companies will try hard to sell you insurance, whether it is necessary for you or not.

Do not buy rental insurance if:

  • Your own personal car insurance policy covers you even in a rental car. Many policies cover you even for leisurely rentals. However, if you do rely on you own insurance make sure it is enough. Some people who have older cars don't insure them for much, which means it will be inadequate for your shiny new rental.
  • You are traveling for an organization that covers you. For instance, many companies who send out employees provide coverage for rental cars.
  • Your charge card covers you.

Consider buying rental insurance if:

  • You do not have any personal auto insurance of any kind.
  • You own auto insurance that doesn't cover rentals.
  • You own auto insurance that wouldn't be enough to cover the car you are renting.

If you do decide that you need rental insurance be careful and read the fine print on all coverage options. Don't let the rental company sell you exorbitant coverage that you don't need.

Q How old do I have to be to rent a car?

A

It is a common misconception that you have to be 25 years or older, by law, to rent a car. Until recently, many car rental services didn't allow anyone under 25 to rent cars as a company policy. This policy is based on the statistical fact that drivers under the age of 25 tend to get in more accidents. However, many companies today allow 21 year olds and even younger to rent cars.

On the other hand, renters under 25 may end up paying more. The top companies charge a daily surcharge for drivers under 25. This is typically around $25 but it can be more for luxury vehicles. To avoid this, compare the top companies for the best deal.

Advertiser Disclosure: MoneySavingPro services are provided at no cost to you, but we may receive a commission from the companies we refer you to. To find out more about how our site works see our Advertiser Disclosure

Full Advertiser Disclosure:

In order for MoneySavingPro to remain a consumer free service, many of the companies covered in our industry reviews compensate MoneySavingPro for new sign ups.

However, the results of our comparison tools, the rankings of the providers, and the information presented is not affected by compensation. Indeed, many of these companies approach us for an advertising partnership after we have already written and published their reviews.

While we try to research and review as many providers as possible in the industries we cover, we have not reviewed every company available.

Our ranking system is independent of compensation and reflects our understanding of the industry and the company based on a variety of factors. The companies that receive the highest rating will always be the providers that we believe offer the best value to the consumer.