We 

Full Advertiser Disclosure:

MoneySavingPro believes everyone should be able to cut their bills and choose the best deal based on their individual requirements. While our site doesn't feature every carrier or provider available on the market, we're sure you'll be able to make significant savings from the information we provide and the free independent tools we create.

How can we provide this service for free? Our partners compensate us. This may influence which plans we compare and review and write about, but it does not effect our recommendations or advice, which are based on thousands of hours of research. Our partners cannot pay us to guarantee favorable reviews of their products or services.

 when you click our links.

Straight Talk vs Tracfone

Compare Straight Talk & Tracfone coverage, plans & deals

man pointing at stars
Tracfone
See PlansPowered by:VerizonAT&TT-Mobile
vs
Straight Talk
See PlansPowered by:T-MobileAT&TVerizon

Tracfone vs Straight Talk comparison

Looking to switch carrier but not sure if Tracfone or Straight Talk is better?

Within this guide, you’ll be able to compare Tracfone and Straight Talk coverage, features, plans and prices side-by-side, so you can decide for yourself which carrier offers the best deal.

Switch & Save $600/yr - Calculate Your Savings

Tracfone vs Straight Talk: Reviews

Our Rating:
Tracfone Review
Our Rating:
Straight Talk Review

Tracfone Review

Straight Talk Review

Pros

  • Large plan selection

  • Widely available in retail stores

  • Unlimited carryover for unused minutes/texts/data

  • Good value for very light users

Pros

  • Unlimited data plans

  • Two-line plan option

  • Plenty of add-ons like international service

  • Easily accessible at WalMart stores

  • Phone financing available

Cons

  • Outdated service model (selling minutes/texts/data piecemeal)

  • Expensive for moderate to heavy data users

  • Overly complex plan structure

Cons

  • Plans not as flexible as some MVNOs


Tracfone vs Straight Talk: Plans

Tracfone Plans

UnlimitedminsUnlimitedtexts
Data1-3GB
Starting at$20
Powered by:VerizonAT&TT-Mobile

Plan

Minutes

Texts

Data

Price

1GB Data

Unlimited

Unlimited

1GB

$20
2GB Data

Unlimited

Unlimited

2GB

$25
3GB Data

Unlimited

Unlimited

3GB

$30

Straight Talk Plans

UnlimitedminsUnlimitedtexts
Data3GB-Unltd
Starting at$35
Powered by:T-MobileAT&TVerizon

Plan

Minutes

Texts

Data

Price

3GB Data

Unlimited

Unlimited

3GB

$35
25GB Data

Unlimited

Unlimited

25GB

$45
Unlimited Data

Unlimited

Unlimited

Unlimited

$55

Tracfone plans start at $20 and Straight Talk plans start as low as $35. With no contract you can get some of the cheapest cell phone plans shopping for a deal with MVNO's like Tracfone and Straight Talk.


Tracfone vs Straight Talk: Coverage

Tracfone is powered by Verizon's National 4G LTE Network

Verizon Coverage Map

Straight Talk is powered by T-Mobile's National 4G LTE Network

T-Mobile Coverage Map

Tracfone is powered by Verizon and Straight Talk is powered by T-Mobile. Coverage can vary depending on your location. You can check their availability in your area our coverage checker.

Find Cheap Cell Phone Plans in Your Area

Tracfone vs Straight Talk: Features

Carrier Features

Tracfone

Straight Talk

Networks:

Verizon, AT&T & T-Mobile

T-Mobile, AT&T & Verizon

Data Speed:

4G LTE, 5G

4G LTE, 5G

3G Network:

CDMA & GSM

CDMA & GSM

Mobile Hotspot:

Bring Your Phone:

Keep Your Number:

Prepaid:

Credit Check:

Customer Service:

8 am to 11.45 pm - 7 days

8 am to 11:45 pm - 7 days

Money Back Guarantee:

5G:

Taxes/fees included:

VoLTE:

WiFi Calling:

Visual Voicemail:

Multi-line Discounts:

Multi-month Discounts:

International Calls:

International Roaming:

Both Tracfone and Straight Talk offer prepaid plans with no contract and you can bring your own phone and keep your phone number. So not only do you get the benefit of saving on a device, but you get the same great service on a cheaper plan.


Tracfone vs Straight Talk: Phone Deals

If you're looking to upgrade, why not save money even more money and buy a refurbished phone?

With most smartphones only making minor changes each year, you can get the great smartphone features with big savings. Find the best unlocked phone deals by comparing phone prices compatible with Tracfone or Straight Talk.

Phone

AT&T

Verizon

T-Mobile

Unlocked

iPhone 11

$349

$599

$599

$349

iPhone 11 Pro

$649

-

-

$649

iPhone 11 Pro Max

$749

-

-

$749

iPhone 12

$579

$829

$829

$579

iPhone 12 mini

$479

$729

$729

$479

iPhone 12 Pro

$749

-

-

$749

iPhone 12 Pro Max

$849

-

-

$849

iPhone SE

$149

$399

$359

$149

iPhone XR

-

$499

$499

$499


Tracfone benefits

  • Operates on AT&T, T-Mobile, and Verizon networks

  • Prepaid service - no contract, credit check, or activation fees

  • Bring your own compatible device or a buy a TracFone phone

  • Call hundreds of international locations with your plan minutes, or add other countries with a global calling card

  • Mobile hotspot/tethering is supported

  • Use your plan minutes to call hundreds of international destinations, including Canada, China, and Mexico

  • Add more countries with a global calling card

  • Three local Mexico virtual phone numbers at no charge so friends and family can call you free

  • Customer service by phone or chat 7 days a week from 8am to 11:45pm EST

Straight Talk benefits

  • Choose from coverage on any one of the three major networks - AT&T, T-Mobile, or Verizon

  • Prepaid wireless plans - no contract, credit check, or activation fees

  • Bring your own device from any network or buy a Straight Talk phone

  • Keep your phone number and stay on your network

  • International talk and text available as an add-on calling card or as a component of a complete cell phone plan

  • 7-day customer support by phone, from 8am to 11:45pm

Compare Smartphone Prices
MSRP:$399$149
Apple iPhone SE
 Green smartphone

Tracfone vs Straight Talk FAQs

What's the difference between Tracfone and Straight Talk?

The main difference between Tracfone and Straight Talk are plan prices and features. Both offer cheap cell phone plans powered by the major networks.

What networks do Tracfone and Straight Talk use?

Tracfone is powered by Verizon, AT&T & T-Mobile and Straight Talk runs on T-Mobile, AT&T & Verizon.

What phones are compatible with Tracfone and Straight Talk?

Most newer handsets are compatible if they're unlocked, but if you're not sure you can check phone compatibility with our IMEI checker.

Does a Tracfone phone work with Straight Talk?

If your Tracfone phone is unlocked it should work with Straight Talk. Most of the latest handsets are compatible but you can check your phone's compatibility with the carrier before purchasing.

Rob Webber
Rob Webber

Rob has 15+ years experience in the US and UK running price comparison sites for cell phone plans, smartphone deals, TV, and internet. He loves thinking outside of the box to build tools that empower consumers to make more informed decisions.

The Best Prices on the Best Networks