Worried about switching carriers and getting stuck with bad service or surprise fees? You're not alone. Many people hesitate to leave their current provider because they assume cheaper plans mean worse coverage or hidden costs.
US Mobile and Consumer Cellular both offer prepaid phone plans that cut costs compared to big wireless, but they focus on different types of users.
US Mobile is designed for those who want a high-end experience with priority data, international perks, and flexible plans. Consumer Cellular, on the other hand, is built for simplicity, offering affordable plans with AARP discounts and customer service geared toward seniors.
So, should you choose US Mobile for premium perks or Consumer Cellular for no-fuss savings?
US Mobile vs Consumer Cellular plans
Winner: US Mobile
US Mobile gives you more plan flexibility with both customizable and unlimited plans. You can build your own plan to fit your exact needs or choose from unlimited options that include unlimited priority data.
Consumer Cellular keeps it simple with easy-to-understand plans that work well for light data users. Their AARP discounts make them a great choice for seniors, but their plans become less competitive for those who need more data.
If you want a fully customizable plan with priority data, US Mobile is the better choice. If you prefer a simple, affordable plan with senior discounts, Consumer Cellular is a solid option.
US Mobile plans
US Mobile unlimited data plan
- Verizon, AT&T & T-Mobile 5G & 4G LTE networks
- Unlimited talk, text and data
- Instant online activation
| Carrier | Network | Data | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| US Mobile 2GB plan | Verizon, AT&T & T-Mobile 5G/4G Coverage | 2GB | $10/mo |
| US Mobile 5GB plan | Verizon, AT&T & T-Mobile 5G/4G Coverage | 5GB | $15/mo |
| US Mobile unlimited data plan | Verizon, AT&T & T-Mobile 5G/4G Coverage | Unltd | $17.50/mo |
| US Mobile 10GB plan | Verizon, AT&T & T-Mobile 5G/4G Coverage | 10GB | $20/mo |
| US Mobile unlimited data plan | Verizon, AT&T & T-Mobile 5G/4G Coverage | Unltd | $25/mo |
| US Mobile unlimited data plan | Verizon, AT&T & T-Mobile 5G/4G Coverage | Unltd | $44/mo |
Consumer Cellular plans
Consumer Cellular unlimited data plan
- T-Mobile 5G & 4G LTE network
- Unlimited talk, text and data
- Instant online activation
| Carrier | Network | Data | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Consumer Cellular 1GB plan | T-Mobile 5G/4G Coverage | 1GB | $20/mo |
| Consumer Cellular 5GB plan | T-Mobile 5G/4G Coverage | 5GB | $25/mo |
| Consumer Cellular 10GB plan | T-Mobile 5G/4G Coverage | 10GB | $35/mo |
| Consumer Cellular unlimited data plan | T-Mobile 5G/4G Coverage | Unltd | $50/mo |
US Mobile vs Consumer Cellular coverage
Winner: US Mobile
US Mobile operates on Verizon, AT&T and T-Mobile's networks, meaning you get access to all of the major networks.
Consumer Cellular runs on AT&T and T-Mobile, both of which offer strong coverage. According to OpenSignal's 2025 report, T-Mobile leads in 5G availability, while Verizon and AT&T provide the most consistent nationwide coverage.
Since both carriers offer reliable service across multiple networks, the best choice depends on which provider has stronger coverage in your area.
US Mobile coverage
US Mobile is powered by Verizon, T-Mobile and AT&T 5G & 4G LTE wireless networks.
Consumer Cellular coverage
Consumer Cellular is powered by AT&T and T-Mobile 5G & 4G LTE wireless networks.
View Consumer Cellular coverage map
Data speeds: Will your connection slow down?
Winner: US Mobile
Many people hesitate to switch to a low-cost carrier because they assume speeds will be slower. While both of these providers lease network space from major carriers, US Mobile's Unlimited Premium plan offers priority data, meaning you won't experience slowdowns even during high-traffic times.
US Mobile's Unlimited Premium includes unlimited data, while Consumer Cellular's unlimited plan includes high-speed data up to 50GB per month.
If you want the fastest speeds and priority data, US Mobile is the better choice. If you're a light data user and just need a reliable plan, Consumer Cellular is still a great option.
Features and perks: Which provider gives you more?
Winner: US Mobile
US Mobile stands out for premium perks, making it a great choice for users who want more than just a basic phone plan.
Some of the extra benefits include:
- Priority data on Unlimited Premium
- Free international roaming on select plans
- Streaming perks like free Netflix, Spotify, and Disney+ on family plans
Consumer Cellular focuses more on simplicity, offering AARP discounts and award-winning customer service but lacks premium perks like priority data and entertainment benefits.
If you want extra perks and premium features, US Mobile is the better pick. If you prefer an easy-to-use plan with solid customer service, Consumer Cellular is a strong choice.
US Mobile vs Consumer Cellular plan features
| Carrier Features | US Mobile | Consumer Cellular |
|---|---|---|
| Networks | Verizon, T-Mobile & AT&T | AT&T & T-Mobile |
| Data Speed | 5G & 4G LTE | 5G & 4G LTE |
| 3G Network | GSM & CDMA | GSM |
| Mobile Hotspot | Yes | Yes |
| Bring Your Phone | Yes | Yes |
| Keep Your Number | Yes | Yes |
| Contract | Prepaid | Prepaid |
| Credit Check | No | No |
| Customer Service | 24/7 | Mon-Fri 5am to 6pm / Sat-Sun 6am to 5pm |
| Money Back Guarantee | Yes - 100 days | No |
| 5G | Yes | Yes |
| Taxes included | Varies by Location | Varies by Location |
| VoLTE | Yes | Yes |
| WiFi Calling | Yes | Yes |
| Visual Voicemail | Yes | No |
| Multi-line Discounts | Yes | Yes |
| Multi-month Discounts | No | No |
| International Calls | Yes - As add-on | Yes - As add-on |
| International Roaming | Yes | Yes |
Final verdict: Which carrier is the better deal?
- Best for priority data → US Mobile
- Best for senior-friendly pricing → Consumer Cellular
- Best for international roaming → US Mobile
- Best for customer service → Consumer Cellular
If you want a premium phone plan with priority data, streaming perks, and international roaming, US Mobile is the better choice. If you prefer an affordable, no-frills plan with senior discounts and great customer support, Consumer Cellular is a solid alternative.
See our US Mobile review to find out more
Check out our Consumer Cellular review
US Mobile vs Consumer Cellular FAQs
The main difference between US Mobile and Consumer Cellular are plan prices and features. Both offer cheap cell phone plans powered by the major networks.
US Mobile is powered by Verizon, T-Mobile & AT&T and Consumer Cellular runs on T-Mobile.
Most newer handsets are compatible if they're unlocked, but if you're not sure you can check phone compatibility with our IMEI checker.
If your US Mobile phone is unlocked it should work with Consumer Cellular. Most of the latest handsets are compatible but you can check your phone's compatibility with the carrier before purchasing.
Why you can trust me
I know how frustrating it can be to sort through endless phone plans and still feel like you're overpaying. At MoneySavingPro, we don't just look at numbers-we test carriers, compare real-world performance, and break down the fine print so you don't have to.
I've tested US Mobile, Consumer Cellular, and other prepaid carriers to see how they stack up. If there's a better way to save on your phone bill, you'll hear about it here first.
US Mobile comparison guides
- Boost Mobile vs US Mobile
- Mint Mobile vs US Mobile
- Red Pocket vs US Mobile
- Tello vs US Mobile
- Twigby vs US Mobile
- Ultra Mobile vs US Mobile
- US Mobile vs Consumer Cellular
- US Mobile vs Cricket Wireless
- US Mobile vs Metro by T-Mobile
- US Mobile vs Optimum Mobile
- US Mobile vs PureTalk
- US Mobile vs Spectrum Mobile
- US Mobile vs Straight Talk
- US Mobile vs Tracfone
- US Mobile vs Visible
