Founder
About Rob
Rob has 15+ years experience running price comparison & review websites that empower consumers to find the cheapest cell phone services, cell phone deals, home phone, and internet providers available. He has been published in Forbes, US News, Entrepreneur, Huffington Post, Inc.
Rob's Expertise
5G wireless networks, cell phone plans, cell phone deals, MVNOs, internet services, tablets, comparison shopping, money saving, reviewing telecom products & services
MoneySavingPro independently researches the products & services to bring you our recommendations. We may earn money when you click our links - disclosure policy.
Do you live in - or are you moving to - an area that offers both AT&T and Xfinity?
Or perhaps you are considering dropping your current internet provider in favor of either one of these? Then you've come to the right place.
It can be tricky to decide on the right internet company - both offer high-speeds, plus the option of some combination of services, giving you discounts for bundling your internet with things like cable TV and home phone service.
What's the best choice in the end?
Only you can choose, but this review will give you the scoop on AT&T vs Xfinity to help you make an informed decision about which of these internet service providers is right for you.
Xfinity vs AT&T comparison
AT&T vs Xfinity: features comparison
AT&T |
Xfinity |
|
| Monthly Price | $65-190 |
$79.99-164.99 |
| Contract Terms | varies |
1-2 year no contracts |
| Setup | $44 | $89.99 |
| Channels | 155-330 |
45-260+ |
| Max HD Channels | 265 | 130+ |
| DVR Storage | 200 HRs |
300 HRs |
| Download Speeds | 5-1000 Mbps |
15-2000 Mbps |
| Upload Speeds | 4 Mbps |
2-2000 Mbps |
| Availability | 50 states |
40+ states |
AT&T vs Xfinity: internet deals
AT&T offers a few plans that cover your basic internet user, your gamer, and your small business. They've simplified it so you're not overwhelmed with options which makes it easier for you if you're looking to bundle. But, as we said, their packages are a bit pricier than Xfinity's plans.
AT&T internet deals
- Download
- 300-5,000 Mbps
- Channels
- Calls
- Monthly Price
- $55-180
Pros
Flexible bundling options
Quickly expanding fiber network
DSL service available
Extensive rural availability
Cons
Data caps on some plans
Contract required for best deals
AT&T offers internet, TV & landline services with plans starting at $55.
AT&T Internet Only Plans
Package |
Internet |
TV |
Phone |
Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Internet 300 |
300 Mbps |
|
|
$55.00 |
|
Internet 500 |
500 Mbps |
|
|
$65.00 |
|
Internet 1000 |
1000 Mbps |
|
|
$80.00 |
|
Internet 2000 |
2000 Mbps |
|
|
$110.00 |
|
Internet 5000 |
5000 Mbps |
|
|
$180.00 |
AT&T TV Plans
Package |
Internet |
TV |
Phone |
Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Entertainment |
|
160 Channels |
|
$64.99 |
|
Choice |
|
185 Channels |
|
$69.99 |
|
Ultimate |
|
250 Channels |
|
$89.99 |
AT&T Triple Play Bundles
Package |
Internet |
TV |
Phone |
Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Internet 300 + Entertainment TV + Phone |
300 Mbps |
160 Channels |
Unlimited |
$154.98 |
|
Internet 300 + Choice TV + Phone |
300 Mbps |
185 Channels |
Unlimited |
$159.99 |
|
Internet 300 + Ultimate TV + Phone |
300 Mbps |
250 Channels |
Unlimited |
$179.99 |
AT&T internet only plans
| Package | Speed | Price |
|---|---|---|
AT&T Internet 300 |
300 Mbps | $55 |
AT&T Internet 500 |
500 Mbps | $65 |
AT&T Internet 1000 |
1000 Mbps | $80 |
AT&T Internet 2000 |
2000 Mbps | $110 |
AT&T Internet 5000 |
5000 Mbps | $180 |
When it comes to Xfinity internet plans offer a couple more options than AT&T. Their speeds range from 15-1000 Mbps making them perfect for those with minimal internet needs to businesses alike. Xfinity internet plans are also slightly cheaper than AT&T making them more appealing.
Xfinity internet deals
- Download
- 400-1,200 Mbps
- Channels
- Calls
- Monthly Price
- $40-80
Pros
Lightning fast options
Multiple speed choices
Large bundle selection
Contract and no-contract options
Widespread availability
Hotspot access away from home
Cons
Less than stellar customer service ratings
Known for its occasional outages
Xfinity offers internet, TV & landline services with plans starting at $40.
Xfinity Internet Only Plans
Package |
Internet |
TV |
Phone |
Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
400 Mbps Internet |
400 Mbps |
|
|
$39.99 |
|
800 Mbps Internet |
800 Mbps |
|
|
$59.99 |
|
1000 Mbps Internet |
1000 Mbps |
|
|
$69.99 |
|
1200 Mbps Internet |
1200 Mbps |
|
|
$79.99 |
Xfinity TV Plans
Package |
Internet |
TV |
Phone |
Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Basic TV |
|
10 Channels |
|
$20.00 |
|
Extra TV |
|
125 Channels |
|
$67.27 |
|
Preferred TV |
|
185 Channels |
|
$69.99 |
Xfinity Triple Play Bundles
Package |
Internet |
TV |
Phone |
Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Extra TV + Internet 400 + Voice |
400 Mbps |
125 Channels |
Unlimited |
$99.99 |
|
Preferred TV + Internet 1000 + Voice |
1000 Mbps |
185 Channels |
Unlimited |
$109.99 |
Xfinity internet only plans
| Package | Speed | Price |
|---|---|---|
Xfinity 400 Mbps Internet |
400 Mbps | $39.99 |
Xfinity 800 Mbps Internet |
800 Mbps | $59.99 |
Xfinity 1000 Mbps Internet |
1000 Mbps | $69.99 |
Xfinity 1200 Mbps Internet |
1200 Mbps | $79.99 |
AT&T vs Xfinity: bundle deals
AT&T internet offers quite a few packages that include FastAccess DSL and Fiber Internet. Unfortunately, the options can be very limited depending on the area.
However, you might be lucky enough to live in an area that is covered by up to 940 Mbps download and upload speeds. Fortunately, U-Verse covers 21 states, with its fiber optic service now being implemented in many areas.
Here's the good news: you can avoid data caps entirely if you take advantage of the unlimited internet data usage option. You are eligible for this option if you bundle together AT&T's internet and TV services, purchase the "Internet 1000" speed tier, or flat-out buy the unlimited data usage option for $30 more a month.
AT&T offers more HD channels compared to Comcast and has solid internet tiers at reasonable fees. If you need more information regarding AT&T U-verse TV, you can always refer to either our AT&T TV Packages or Channel Lineup guides.
AT&T bundle deals
| Package | Speed | Channels | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 300 Mbps | 160 | $119.99 |
|
| 300 Mbps | 185 | $124.99 |
|
| 300 Mbps | 250 | $144.99 |
AT&T triple play packages
| Package | Speed | Channels | Phone Plan | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 300 Mbps | 160 | Unlimited | $154.98 |
|
| 300 Mbps | 185 | Unlimited | $159.99 |
|
| 300 Mbps | 250 | Unlimited | $179.99 |
Xfinity service is considered to be the largest in the nation, but despite its coverage, Xfinity customer service has one of the worst reputations in the industry.
That being said, Xfinity does offer some reasonably speedy packages, with one of the tiers being the fastest available in the United States: 2000 Mbps (2 Gigabit). There's also a 2 Gigabit internet is a tier used primarily by businesses.
Admittedly, Xfinity and AT&T are at neck-and-neck when it comes to prices and speeds. If you need information regarding Xfinity's cable services, you can always look into our Xfinity Channel Lineup or Xfinity Cable Packages guides.
Xfinity bundle deals
| Package | Speed | Channels | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 400 Mbps | 10 | $54.99 |
|
| 400 Mbps | 125 | $89.99 |
|
| 800 Mbps | 185 | $99.99 |
Xfinity triple play packages
| Package | Speed | Channels | Phone Plan | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 400 Mbps | 125 | Unlimited | $99.99 |
|
| 1000 Mbps | 185 | Unlimited | $109.99 |
AT&T vs Xfinity: internet speed
The battle of internet speed is one being fought with every major network.
Xfinity offers a wide variety of speeds that range from 15-1000 Mbps. Their plans have a lot to offer for every type of customer. AT&T on the other hand only has three speeds available ranging from 100-1000 Mbps.
Either provider would give you adequate service if they cover your area. If given the option though, and if you're a lite internet user, you should go for Xfinity. Other than that, you're good to take on either of these providers.
Admittedly, Xfinity and AT&T are at neck-and-neck when it comes to prices and speeds. If you need information regarding Xfinity's cable services, you can always look into our Xfinity Channel Lineup or Xfinity Cable Packages guides.
Let's take a look at how their coverage compares.
AT&T vs Xfinity: coverage
When it comes to availability Xfinity coverage exceeds AT&T coverage. While AT&T is available in 21 states, Xfinity is offered in 36 states.
However, AT&T coverage is strong amongst all the states it's offered in while Xfinity is offered in as little as 1% of the area in some states they "cover".
They both are lacking in large chunks of the country though. AT&T is lacking in the NorthEast and NorthWest regions of the country while Xfinity is lacking in the central states.
Internet providers in my area
AT&T vs Xfinity: customer service
While both providers are pretty neck-and-neck there's quite a difference between AT&T and Xfinity when it comes to customer service.
When it comes to AT&T customer service, the 2016 American Customer Satisfaction Index reports a score of 64 points, which is the industry average. So while this provider's customer service is not the best, it's certainly not the worst either.
As far as customer service, many customers rate Xfinity as one of the poorest in the nation, with complaints leaning toward terrible products, price hikes, and abysmal service. Overall, Xfinity customer service earned an ACSI score of 59, which is just 5 points lower than AT&T's customer service index score.
Don't take our word for it though. Check out what real customers are saying with our AT&T customer reviews and Xfinity customer reviews to see what their actual customers are saying.
AT&T vs Xfinity FAQs
Is AT&T better than Xfinity?
Both AT&T and Xfinity offer bundle deals to help save you money or you can purchase your internet plan on its own. They both have a range of speeds to suit light to heavy internet users and affordable plans for all budgets. You can easily use your ZIP code to check who has the best internet coverage in your area.
Does AT&T or Xfinity have the fastest internet plans?
Both offer good download speeds for a heavy internet user, however Xfinity ranks as the fastest internet provider with speeds of up to 2,000 Mbps.
Is AT&T cheaper than Xfinity?
No, AT&T is not cheaper. Xfinity offers lower priced internet packages.
Is Xfinity AT&T or Comcast?
Xfinity is the brand name used by Comcast and is not part of AT&T.
Recap
There you have it: the battle between AT&T vs Xfinity. Both offer speedy internet tiers at a decent price, similar internet data caps, and solid bundles. That being said, AT&T edges Xfinity out due to the HD offerings and better customer service.
So unless you must-have 2000 Mbps download speeds, I would highly recommend turning your attention to AT&T.
Spectrum is one of AT&T's fiercest competitors. To see how the two stack up, check out our comparative guide on AT&T vs Spectrum. You can also compare Xfinity vs Verizon FiOS TV.
