AT&T vs Consumer Cellular: Which carrier is best?

We compared AT&T & Consumer Cellular plans, coverage & customer ratings: Which cell phone service is best for you?
Unlimited data
AT&T 5G & 4G networks
$900/yr Total cost
10GB data
T-Mobile 5G & 4G networks
Save $420/yr
15GB data
T-Mobile 5G & 4G networks
Save $300/yr
25GB data
T-Mobile 5G & 4G networks
Save $180/yr
Cheap AT&T phone plans starting at $5/mo* -Compare Now
Rob Webber
Rob Webber

Rob Webber


About Rob

Rob has 15+ years experience running price comparison & review websites that empower consumers to find the cheapest cell phone services, cell phone deals, home phone, and internet providers available. He has been published in Forbes, US News, Entrepreneur, Huffington Post, Inc.

Rob's Expertise

5G wireless networks, cell phone plans, cell phone deals, MVNOs, internet services, tablets, comparison shopping, money saving, reviewing telecom products & services

- Last updated on January 23rd, 2023

MoneySavingPro independently researches the products & services to bring you our recommendations. We may earn money when you click our links - disclosure policy.

Looking to switch carrier but not sure if Consumer Cellular or AT&T is better?

Within this guide, you'll be able to compare Consumer Cellular and AT&T coverage, features, plans and prices side-by-side, so you can decide for yourself which carrier offers the best deal.

Switch & Save $600/yr - Calculate Your Savings

Consumer Cellular vs AT&T comparison

Our Rating:
View Plans

Read our Consumer Cellular review

Our Rating:
AT&T Plans

Consumer Cellular



  • Simple, solid plan options

  • AARP discount

  • Competitive pricing for light to medium users

  • Device payment plan

  • US-based customer service


  • Great network coverage

  • Fast data speeds

  • Decent value if you buy 4 lines


  • Small plan selection

  • Expensive unlimited data plan


  • Very expensive

  • Limited range of plans

  • Unlimited' plans are not unlimited

  • Hidden fees and taxes

  • Unclear pricing

Consumer Cellular vs AT&T plans

Consumer Cellular plans start at $30 and AT&T plans start at $75. With no contract, you can get some of the cheapest cell phone plans when shopping for a deal with MVNO's like Consumer Cellular.

Consumer Cellular SIM card vertical

Consumer Cellular 3GB

  • T-Mobile 5G & 4G LTE network
  • Unlimited talk and text
  • 3GB data
View Plans

This Consumer Cellular 3GB plan includes unlimited mins, unlimited texts and 3GB data for only $30 per month. Consumer Cellular plans offers wireless coverage on the T-Mobile 5G and 4G LTE network. Read Consumer Cellular review

Consumer Cellular plans




Consumer Cellular 10GB plan



Consumer Cellular 15GB plan



Consumer Cellular 25GB plan



Compare AT&T unlimited plans

Plan Data Monthly Price Annual Cost
AT&T Unlimited Extra Unlimited $75 $900
AT&T Unlimited Elite Unlimited $85 $1,020

AT&T vs Consumer Cellular comparison

Keep your AT&T phone, number & coverage: Save $180 per year


Network Coverage

4G/5G Data


Annual Cost


AT&T 4G & 5G




Consumer Cellular

AT&T 4G & 5G




*Don't waste money on unlimited data - Avg. data usage is only 3-5GB




Consumer Cellular vs AT&T coverage

Consumer Cellular is powered by T-Mobile. Coverage can vary depending on your location. You can check their availability in your area by using our coverage checker.

Consumer Cellular coverage

Consumer Cellular is powered by T-Mobile 5G & 4G LTE wireless networks.

View Consumer Cellular coverage map

T-Mobile coverage map

AT&T coverage

View AT&T coverage map

AT&T coverage map

Find the cheapest cell phone service in your area

Enter your ZIP code below to find the best cell phone service in your area.

Switch & Save $600 per year
Find cheap plans in your area

Consumer Cellular vs AT&T plan features

Carrier Features Consumer CellularAT&T
Networks T-MobileAT&T
Data Speed 5G & 4G LTE5G & 4G LTE
3G Network GSMGSM
Mobile Hotspot
Bring Your Phone
Keep Your Number
Contract No - prepaidNo - Postpaid
Credit Check
Customer Service 24/7
Money Back Guarantee
5G 0
Taxes/fees included
WiFi Calling
Visual Voicemail
Multi-line Discounts
Multi-month Discounts
International Calls
International Roaming

Consumer Cellular vs AT&T customer service

Consumer Cellular customer service

34 Consumer Cellular customer reviews

Contact Consumer Cellular customer care

  • Call (888) 345-5509

  • Tag @consumer_cell on Twitter

AT&T customer service

Contact AT&T customer care

  • Call (800) 331-0500

  • Tag @att on Twitter

AT&T vs Consumer Cellular FAQs

What's the difference between AT&T and Consumer Cellular?

Consumer Cellular is an MVNO with T-Mobile 5G & 4G wireless coverage, they offer cell phone plans starting at $30/mo. While AT&T's phone plans start at $75/mo.

Is Consumer Cellular as good as AT&T?

Consumer Cellular is powered by the T-Mobile network, they offer much cheaper cell phone service than AT&T. However, because Consumer Cellular is an MVNO, data speeds may be slowed during peak times.

Do AT&T phones work with Consumer Cellular?

Most recent AT&T phones should work with Consumer Cellular as long as the device is unlocked. Before signing up, you can check your device's compatibility on the Consumer Cellular website.

Does Consumer Cellular use AT&T network towers?

No. Consumer Cellular operates on the T-Mobile 5G & 4G LTE wireless networks.